Electronic Review of Computer Books

[ ERCB Home | New | Feature | Brief | DDJ | Letters | Links ]

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Vital Statistics

Title Creating Killer Web Sites: The Art of Third-Generation Site Design
Author David Siegel
Publisher Hayden Books
Indianapolis, Indiana
http://www.mcp.com/hayden/
Copyright 1996
ISBN 1-56830-289-4
Pages 270
Price $45.00


Beyond the Valley of the HTMLs

By Siegel's criteria, a first-generation Web site is characterized by seemingly endless pages of wall-to-wall text and lists of hot-links. These sites were the norm two years ago and are unfortunately still quite common today. A second-generation Web site employs in-line graphics, background colors or tiled images, and tables, but is still based on a fairly simple top-down, hierarchical model. Second generation sites are the norm in 1996. A third-generation Web site, on the other hand,
"... uses typographic and visual layout principles to describe a page in two dimensions. Third-generation site designers carefully specify the position and relationships of all elements on the page, retaining fine control of the layout. Third-generation sites use metaphor and visual theme to entice and guide, creating a whole experience for surfers from the first splash screen to the exit."

This is not your mother's book on document tagging and setting up an http server. David Siegel, who approaches the World Wide Web as a medium for artistic expression from the viewpoint of a typographer and graphic designer, has little patience with HTML in its present form. In fact, his main approach to creating a web site is to mock up the pages in Adobe Photoshop, then draw from a hefty toolbox of GIF/JPEG tricks and HTML tweaks until he can exactly reproduce the look he got in the Photoshop documents.

Although I have been creating and administering web sites for a couple of years now, reading this sophisticated, challenging book was a real consciousness-raising experience. The book itself is beautifully designed, if a bit busy visually, and contains countless useful concepts and techniques that you can put to use immediately. The discussions of color cubes, palettes, animated GIFs, and PDF files are particularly unique and valuable.

The book is supported by a dedicated Web site, http://www.killersites.com, which contains examples from the book, supplementary materials, and links to award-winning "third-generation" sites elsewhere.

-- Ray Duncan


Quick Rating

Readability StarStarStarStar
Originality StarStarStarStar
Organization StarStarStar
Accuracy StarStarStarStar
Consistency StarStarStarStar
Depth StarStarStarStar
Timeliness StarStarStarStar
Editing StarStarStar
Design StarStarStarStar
Overall Value StarStarStarStar

Explanation of ERCB rating scale: No stars = unacceptable, 1 Star = marginal, 2 Stars = average, 3 Stars = above average, 4 Stars = exceptional.


Copyright © 1996 Electronic Review of Computer Books
Created 9/7/96 / Last modified 9/7/96 / webmaster@ercb.com